Miami-FIU Punishment is BS

[outrunner]

Only ONE frickin' game.  > > > WTF Miami is playing DUKE. Great punishment. > > >

All respect for Miami just went out the window. FIU isn't too far behind.

All

Criminal

Conference

[Bull Dozer]

To play devils advocate......I didnt  see the major media out for blood when that clemson and south carolina fight a few years back.  This is being pumped up because of the U's reputation.

[windbane]

and FIU is playing alabama, a game they wouldnt have won anyway.  i think the NCAA might throw down some more punishments.  this brawl was different with a lot more stomping on people that were on the ground and at least that one guy using his helmet as a weapon.

[Economics_Nerd82]

Should be at the very least TWO games suspension for everyone.

[Guest r_to_the_izzo]

Thats hockey everybody, bench clearing brawls are common place er.......

All seriousness: the stompers, slammers, helmet and crutch swingers need scholies revoked.

[Guest]

You really need to keep up with the news...

Fallout From Miami, FIU Reverberates

Miami Extends 1 Suspension, Florida International Dismisses 2 in Wake of Bench-Clearing Melee

MIAMI Oct 16, 2006 (AP) Of all the disturbing images from the sideline-clearing brawl between Miami and Florida International, three stood out more than others. The players responsible were punished swiftly and sternly Monday.

Miami's Anthony Reddick, who wielded his helmet as a weapon before smashing it into an FIU player, had his one-game suspension increased to an indefinite one, leaving the remainder of his season in serious doubt.

Meanwhile, FIU's new sanctions were considerably tougher: The Golden Panthers dismissed two players, Marshall McDuffie Jr. and Chris Smith, and issued 16 other players all who were originally handed one-game suspensions indefinite breaks from the game.

"This is certainly embarrassing. It's disgraceful. It's amazing. I've run out of words," FIU coach Don Strock said. "There's no place for it in college football or football period. This is way overboard. I apologize to all the fans of college football for this taking place."

The two dismissed players will remain on scholarship at FIU.

Officials from Miami, FIU and the Atlantic Coast and Sun Belt conferences issued 31 one-game suspensions to 13 Hurricanes and 18 Golden Panthers late Sunday, while both schools warned further punishment was possible.

Miami athletic director Paul Dee and ACC commissioner John Swofford decided Monday that Reddick who charged across the field within the first 30 seconds of the fight starting and swung his helmet wildly at FIU players, striking at least one merited more than the one-game suspension.

"Additional measures were needed," Swofford said.

FIU said its suspended players all would have to complete 10 hours of anger management counseling and 50 hours of community service, plus would be on athletic probation for the remainder of the year.

Further, all FIU players and coaches will need to complete community service projects.

"This is something that's not going to be tolerated," FIU athletic director Pete Garcia said. "We've got to use this as an example to the young kids in South Florida and all over. They need to know that yes, football is very competitive. Our society is very competitive. But we've got to make sure that we teach the youth in South Florida what's acceptable behavior and what's not."

Chris Smith and McDuffie both took shots at Miami holder Matt Perrelli shortly after the fight began with 9 minutes left in the third quarter Saturday night. Smith wrestled Perrelli down and appeared to punch him in the chin, shortly before McDuffie kicked Perrelli's head.

"For us," Garcia said, "one incident is one incident too many."

Miami said it would order its suspended players to complete community service as well.

Dee added that the university's athletic department "re-emphasized" the importance of sportsmanship to coach Larry Coker and members of his staff. The brawl was the third on-field incident in Miami's past seven games; the Hurricanes also fought with LSU after losing last season's Peach Bowl and trampled Louisville's midfield Cardinals logo before playing there last month, an act viewed as taunting.

"The coaches will be held accountable for any violation of this principle," Dee said.

Coker was not available for comment Monday. He is scheduled to hold his regular weekly news conference Tuesday.

The ACC and Miami (4-2) suspended Reddick, Carlos Armour, Chris Barney, James Bryant, Tyrone Byrd, DajLeon Farr, Ryan Hill, Bruce Johnson, Charlie Jones, Brandon Meriweather, Brian Monroe, Derrick Morse and Randy Phillips.

All will miss Saturday's game at winless Duke.

"Miami has quality depth at every position," Duke coach Ted Roof said. "It's not like they're going to fall off the side of the mountain."

In addition to McDuffie and Chris Smith, the Sun Belt and FIU (0-7) suspended Michael Alls, Scott Bryant, Roland Clark, Michael Dominquez, John Ellis, Cory Fleming, Reginald Jones, Robert Mitchell, Quintin Newman, Luis Pena, Jarvis Penerton, Julian Reams, Lionell Singleton, Samuel Smith, Mannie Wellington and Chandler Williams.

They'll miss FIU's next game Oct. 28 at Alabama at least.

"We're going to go about business as usual," Strock said. "I've been around the game a long time. It's an embarrassing moment for me as the head coach and it's something we'll certainly rectify."

And Monday's fallout wasn't limited to on-field actions, either.

Former Miami player Lamar Thomas lost his TV analyst job with Comcast Sports SouthEast Monday over comments he made during the brawl.

CSS will also edit out Thomas' comments before replaying the game later this week.

"You come into our house, you should get your behind kicked," Thomas said during the fight. "You don't come into the OB playing that stuff. You're across the ocean over there. You're across the city. You can't come over to our place talking noise like that. You'll get your butt beat."

Said CSS general manager Mark Fuhrman: "We were disappointed in the incident that happened on the field and regret the way it was handled in the broadcast booth."

The NCAA, in a statement released Monday, called the fight "wholly unacceptable" and said it hoped the added sanctions taken by Miami and FIU shows "that such behavior is not tolerated."

Miami president Donna Shalala said in an open letter that the fight was "outrageous."

"Regardless of who started it, this was an embarrassing display of unsportsmanlike behavior," Shalala wrote. "Fortunately there were no injuries."

AP Sports Writers Steven Wine in Miami and Michael Marot in Indianapolis contributed to this report.

Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

[outrunner]

To play devils advocate......I didnt  see the major media out for blood when that clemson and south carolina fight a few years back.  This is being pumped up because of the U's reputation.

Clemson and SC declined their bowl game. Thats alot worse than Duke. As I remember the fight wasn't as bad as this one was either.

You are right about Miami's reputation pumping this up. Three fights in one year (LSU, Louisville, FIU). Don't get me wrong, FIU is just as bad for this, but UM is out of control without anything being done except wrist slaps.

[windbane]

JimUSFSig is just a showoff  

[Who'sYourData?]

Let's see, FIU has had one incident in their history, and they've taken much stronger action than "the U", which has had three incidents in the last seven games.  Big talk from Swofford, who says "Additional measures were needed" and proceeds to change one measley suspension from one game to indefinite.  Meriweather in particular has had his share of incidents recently.  He should have been kicked off the team for stomping on defenseless players.

Makes you proud of the tougher suspensions for our players who didn't even try to harm anyone.

[Joe]

This is STRANGELY similar to the downfall of Ron Zook at Florida.

- Loses a couple games in a year that many thought would be a make or break year for the coach

- Team gets in a fight and the media is all over it (Ron Zook and the frat)

I have a strange feeling that Miami is going to lose a game it shouldn't and Coker will be canned the next day. (ala Miss State over Florida that year)