Haven't read everything so if I'm duplicating an idea, my apologies.
I think one of the most overlooked advantages of bringing either USF and or UCF into the Big 12 is the impact it will have on other conferences and recruiting. I'm not saying we will keep 5 star players from UF, FSU, or any of the true elite programs. However, if you put the programs in a P5 conference you will see more 4 star and high 3 star players from FL stay home, as they will view both programs as having arrived.
This will make some of the ACC, Big 10 (not Michigan or Ohio State), and even some SEC programs have to look elsewhere for talent, in turn potentially weakening those conferences. Obviously big "if" but an argument could be made.
I know the argument was why couldn't USF do it in the Big East. First, the program was too young. 2nd, the Big 12 (despite criticism) has true tradional power programs. 3rd, I believe it was beginning to happen prior to Leavtt's firing.
Thoughts?