In hindsight signs that he wasn't the guy:
1.) Indecisive/over-thinking. Football is all about instincts and reacting without thinking. If the head coach can't do this he certainly can't teach the players how to
Took him 3 games into year 2 to find a QB, then goes and replaces him immediately after spring practice. If he doesn't trust his own instincts to make that decision there had to be a lot of wishy washy-ness in other decisions.
Constantly taking time outs before big plays. Felt like every game they couldn't get a playcall made in time and had to burn a timeout that could have been used in crunch time. If you don't know the right play within 30 seconds you're not trusting your instincts.
2.) Too timid. You got to have some aggression in this game. You have to have a different gear than nice and conservative. Toughness and aggression from the coach can cause stress in practice. Practicing with a stressful atmosphere makes you better in close late games.
Punting in plus territory. Happened a few times, one specifically I remember is SMU last year. Down 10-0 in the 1st quarter, 4th and 5 from their 34 and we punt. Go for it or kick a field goal and i'm fine, just anything besides punt.
Always finding a way to **** up close games. There has been 11 games in Jeff Scott's tenure where it was a 1 score game at some point in the 4th quarter. We have lost every single one. 0-11
The moment where I went from optimistic we are turning things around to doing mental gymnastics trying to justify hopes that Jeff Scott is still the guy? Tulsa in 2021. 4th quarter starts and we are up 31-20 with Tulsa starting at their own 1 yard line.
If being up two scores at home vs ******* Tulsa (with them needing to drive 99 yards just to pull it into a 1 score game) is too big of a moment to just put the foot on the gas and put them away you'll never be able to.