Andre Hall vs. Marlon Mack

[Flowers4Heisman]

If you had to choose, who would you pick as your starter RB?

I watched the UAB game from 2004, thanks to Python, and Hall had a big game. Hall had a lot of speed and power. But I think Mack has vision and cuts.

 

[Massbull]

No doubt Mack,he's bigger ,stronger and He has next level ability. Hall was good but defiantly a step below Mack.

Edited December 19, 2015 by Massbull

[Brad]

Andre was a great running back for the Bulls, but Mack is the best yet.

[Bulls 8_va]

I don't think a team Marlon Mack is on would put up a GOOSE EGG in his schools FIRST EVER BOWL GAME.  

#GOBULLS

[Flowers4Heisman]

I don't think a team Marlon Mack is on would put up a GOOSE EGG in his schools FIRST EVER BOWL GAME.  

#GOBULLS

Hey, it wasn't his fault. RUSHING: USF-HALL, Andre 19-118; PONTON, Ricky 8-41; RECEIVING: USF-HALL, Andre 2-49;

http://www.gousfbulls.com/pdf7/26320.pdf

[nobull.Bulls]

In Andres defense of that bowl game, there was Mario Williams and I believe another first rounder on that NC state d-line. 

Mack is the better RB thou. Speed, vision, agility, he's got it all. 

[Brad]

Any Bull knows the offensive problems with that first ever bowl bound team....

Anytime they tried to stray from involving Hall it backfired, especially during a brief quarterback change in the third quarter. With Julmiste struggling against the Wolfpack's defense, USF sent in freshman Carlton Hill to change the pace.

USF Falls 14-0 To NC State In Meineke Car Care Bowl

[MMW]

Andre Hall all day long.   I love Mack but Hall was a one man show.  Pat Julmiste was our QB and the defense always knew they had to stop Hall and couldn't.  

 

[Who'sYourData?]

At this point I would still go with Hall.  The talent around Mack is mediocre, while the talent around Hall was absolutely atrocious.  That Hall was able to do as much as he did when he was the only player on the offense that the defense even had to look at is still amazing to me.

[Triple B]

2 hours ago, Bulls 8_va said:

I don't think a team Marlon Mack is on would put up a GOOSE EGG in his schools FIRST EVER BOWL GAME.  

#GOBULLS

I don't think a team Andre Hall is on would put up a GOOSE EGG against UCF .... just sayin.