^^^ This is my stance on the issue of USF-UCF.
In college sports you need a rival, and rivalries are not made, they just happen. While what makes a rivalry is debateable, I think what makes a good one is hate, and UCF hates USF, and in my view we are not too fond of UCF either.
I just don't see that same level of hate between UF, FSU, Miami and USF. Like cophbulls said Aurburn and Alabama hate each other, as do Georgia and Florida, Ohio State and Michigan. I see the core of what makes a rivalry as hate, or an extreme dislike because you consider the other school, team, or group to be inferior.
I'm not estatic over the fact that this is happening, but we should embrace the suck and try to make something out of this. A trophy helps to elevate this thing to the next level, lets just hope that they make the trophy into something realtively cool and not something gay.
I think a shovel is the best option in my opinion, we already introduced a shovel back when we played UCF the last time.