JPP or Selvie who is having the better year?

[bulls96go]

different teams and situations but a comparison could be made.

Nate Allen is doing very well...rookie of the year IMO.

[Bull Matrix]

I think they are both having good years! They are being productive and they are stayng out of trouble. I am really happy for Selvie tough because we was getting blasted about his weight and speed. I think he is showing that  he can play this game.

[Matt]

.

Nate Allen is doing very well...rookie of the year IMO.

do you mean rookie of the year for the guys from USF who were drafted??

cause Suh is walking away with this award

[nobull.Bulls]

I think JPP is having the better year, but is also on a much better team.

Get Bradford some receivers and a  LB on D and the Rams win 4 more games.

[TRCCBulls]

JPP is having the better year. His contract is bigger!

[HappyHourHero]

JPP is having a better second half of the season. He was a non factor it seemed like until about 4 games ago.

[Greg Auman]

Hard to make a case for Selvie. He has 18 tackles and 1.5 sacks, with no sacks in the last two months. Pierre-Paul has 24 tackles, 4 sacks and two forced fumbles, and all four sacks have come in the last three games. He's coming on strong.

And Allen for rookie of the year? He has three picks, but none since Week 4. Don't get me wrong, I'm an Eagles guy, but he's not in the running for ROY. Suh will win that. Allen is probably the second-best rookie safety this year -- he has 45 tackles, but T.J. Ward with the Browns has 104 tackles and two picks.

[Bull Matrix]

With Nate Allen out with injury, I think the Eagles are toast. I see them going into a big slump now.

[BullFan98]

JPP, plus he is being acknowleged by the anchors as a big talent for the Giants.  He played great against the Eagles.  Plus it doesn't hurt that when he does well USF is brought up. 

[Jihme]

JPP without a doubt