caddy or bush?

[fishinBULL]

i was talking to my coworkers at publix today and i asked if you had the choice of having reggie bush or caddillac williams as your starting running back next year,who would you choose?  They all answered Bush.

ok.

My counter argument was that while Bush is great and all, he has never played an NFL game.  We've only seen him play college ball.  On the other hand, Cadillac has shown the NFL he can play and in just one year has broken NFL records and won rookie of the year.  

yet they still insist that Bush must be a better back.

[flsportsfan83]

and that is why they work at Publix. I hate the Bucs but Caddy will be a much better NFL back.

[BigGameBulls]

and that is why they work at Publix. I hate the Bucs but Caddy will be a much better NFL back.

True...but both will be better then Ronnie Brown.

[Velcro]

I'd pick Bush.  Sure Cadillac has an extra year experience, but Bush is the most explosive player to come out of the draft in decades.

Cadillac could be a great back for many years and Bush could be just a good back, but Bush has the potential to be one of the best ever.  That makes up for the 1 (just 1) year of experience.

[Joe]

Bush,

Bush might not have the stats Caddy will, but he's gonna be great.

However this is like picking between Bass and Harp for me, gimmie either I'll enjoy it regardless.

[Velcro]

Now that is an example I can understand

[Triple B]

and that is why they work at Publix. I hate the Bucs but Caddy will be a much better NFL back.

Don't be knocking Publix now or I may have to STK on you ............. I'd roll the dice and take Bush.

[flsportsfan83]

Ill take Ronnie Brown over all of them

[fishinBULL]

Ill take caddy and publix sucks...I cant wait to get out of that hell whole.

just 6 more years...

[Velcro]

Ill take Ronnie Brown over all of them

Uh, no.  I'd take either of them over Brown.

The dolphins blow.