Other than you, who said that he would be our savior? He's a decent QB that has been in the "heat of the battle" against top ranked opponents.
EDIT: He had offers from: Louisville, Pitt, USF, Stanford, and Arkansas. If he was good enough for us then, then why not now?
You don't take a 1 yr transfer player unless they are going to be emphatically better than what you've got. I don't see Trickett as any better than Floyd. I'd rather play Floyd or White for a year to get them in the system then bring in a guy like Tricket for a one and done. IMO you only bring in a one and and done if they are a savior
Based on what we have seen from floyd, and the fact that White is a freshman, I wouldn't rule out that Tricket is emphatically better. At least he has had success at some point in his college career. If he can come in and beat them out, theres no reason he shouldn't be accepted with open arms. Better team equals better recruits and more exposure at an important time.