Not sure why it wouldn't, the announcers even broached the subject. Not saying it will do anything, but it will be a topic in sports news, almost certainly, when discussing the bowl season and transition to the new format.
Because the AAC was 4-8 against P5 teams this season and 2 of those wins were by teams that will not be here next year. The AAC is currently 2-2 in bowl games. One of those wins is by a team that will not be here next year. The AAC had no OOC wins over a ranked opponent in the regular season. That means the case for the AAC to become a power conference is: Cincinatti beat Purdue. UCF beat Penn State. UCF beat #6 Baylor. If anything it makes a case for a P5 conference to snatch UCF.
If the AAC champ can beat the Big 12 champ is enough to get the argument going. You are talking about teams in transition. UCF is one of the only current stable AAC teams with a long term coaching staff.
Yes, I see where you're coming from. However, the WAC did the same thing in 2006. Boise State beat the Big 12 Champion (Oklahoma). That didn't mean that they should have been proclaimed a BCS conference. The AAC wants to have the same respect that the Big East did. In order for that to happen, it needs to do what the Big East did in 2004 (when UM and VT left) and have 2-3 teams step up. The first year after Miami and VT split, Pitt finished the season in the Top 25. West Virginia spent most of that season ranked as well and had some good wins. The next year, WVU finished at #5 and Louisville came in and had an impressive showing. USF knocked off the #9 team (Louisville). In 2006, three teams finished the season ranked. Conference members were having some decent showings in bowls and OOC games. We need a few years of that in order for us to have the power conference talk. There will no onger be any BCS games to showcase our teams.
Unfortunately, the AAC has a much tougher road ahead of it than the Big East did ten years ago. It was contractually locked into a BCS game, it had a decent TV contract, the talent of the leftover teams was pretty good. In short, the Big East was in a pretty good position when it went through it's rebuilding and for the rest of it's existence and there were still naysayers arguing that it didn't belong as a power conference. We're nowhere near having that conversation now.