1. Going back to the first game I attended, it was a Halloween night vs Cinci in '03 (maybe?) and Selmon Jr intercepted a pass in OT to clinch the victory.
2. A dropped pass in the endzone by a tight end at RayJay vs Rutgers, possibly in OT.
3. A missed short field goal @ Rutgers as time expired that would have won the game. We lost, I believe, in OT which ticked me off so much that we shortened our trip and didn't go up to Syracuse the next week where, of course, we won.
Rutgers seems to be a commonality in these bad things.