Maybe, but they both started with similar situations and then Herman got dealt a big blow, losing his starting QB. He inherited a 5-7 team (Charlotte, SE La., Rice, UAB and FIU), but it would be hard to say it was a program in good shape. If they end up in the mix for the league title at the end of the year and we struggle all the way to the finish line, I’d be pretty comfortable in making a call on the hires.