So for the record, I’m not outright against the stadium but if your future outlook changes while you are in the planning stages of a $300+ million dollar project, I certainly would expect that renewed discussions are in order. As another poster point out, the summary write-up proposal indicated that USF was already over estimating potential benefits according to an independent evaluator. If USF was already basing the ROI on rosy projections and we just took another step down/were left behind (potentially until 2036), the entire justification (financially) may no longer be there.
As far as your other points, we had plenty of traditions in the making when we were winning in Raymond James in the late 2000s and the students also didn’t have a problem with making it to those games in droves. Winning does that. Further, it doesn’t seem like the on campus basketball arena is drawing the students attendance just because we built one. I’m for investing in football in whatever way gets USF back to relevance the quickest. May be that’s the stadium, may be it’s a payment to buy our way in to a conference (a la SMU), may be it’s a donation towards FSUs ACC contact buyout. I’d personally be ecstatic to be sitting alongside 40k other USF fans again in RayJay playing the nationally recognized teams again, win or lose.