"The success he had at South Florida, including at one point being ranked number two nationally, has not been anywhere close to repeated since his departure."
Well that sentence hurts.
Pretty much sums it up.
I like Jim as much as the next guy but there was a clusterfck of strange events that got us ranked at #2. Yea, I wish we were that good again but we were never the 2nd best team in the country and we never finished ranked in the Top 25. Edit: Or did we finish 24 one year before I started following the team?
Yes but right now we don't have a cluster of strange events that would make the teams of the last 4 years hang within 14 points of the teams between 2007 and 2009.
At the time in the season we beat Auburn (who went to Gainesville and beat UF 2 weeks later), beat WVU (who would later get back to #2 and squander a national title shot), destroyed the crap out of UNC and were sitting at 6-0 with better wins than anyone else. Were we the second best team in the country? No. At that point in the season did anyone have a better resume? No.
And that seemed to be the M O of CJL teams. Lack of depth, better coaching, etc. all excuses/reasons have been used for our annual collapse in conference play.
I wonder what Harlan would do if we CJL was still here and we continued with the trend of making low end bowl games, but NEVER sniffing a conference title?
If CJL had been coaching the last 5 years, we'd probably be 8-5 or 9-4 most years. We may even be in another conference ( ). Or maybe we are in this conference but we win because we don't play anybody. We'll never know.
With the perspective of the last 5 years though, I think we'd all be just fine with those 8-5 seasons again.