Experts: Rank the Qbs coming out of HS

[beastiebull]

Basing your evaluatiojns solely on what they have done in HS and their perceived potential at the next level.    Just curious how our current QBs fare in comparison to those that have jilted us/played for us in the past.  1-7 #1 being the best.

Pat Julmiste

Ronnie Banks

Cornelius ingram

Matt Grothe

AD McPherson

Carlton Hill

Brent Schaeffer

[Velcro]

1 Schaeffer

2 McPherson

3 Grothe

4 Hill

5 Ingram

6 Banks

7 Julmiste

[beastiebull]

Hill and Grothe both better than Ingram?  Seems everyone was so excited about him last year.  Nice to be able to now view him as an afterthought

[Velcro]

I'd say Hill and Ingram are very similar... Grothe is on another level since he is similarly elusive but is much more polished and heady.  I put Hill over Ingram because I think he will actually see the field, where Ingram knew he was going to redshirt football.

[sdgukhsdgl]

Hill is faster/quicker and prob a more versatile athlete than Ingram, both played against 1A competition and both are pretty raw as passers so the nod goes to Hill

[Velcro]

Grothe = runner up Mr. Football... so he beats both of them, without question.

He should be a 4 star recruit!  He is in our thebullspen.com rankings

[usfinthere]

What if you threw in our past starters?  

I never followed USF football until I started at USF 1999, and certainly didn't follow recruiting.  So, I'm curious to know how these two quarterbacks were thought of when they came out of high school.

Blackwell

Barnhardt

[Velcro]

I'd say they'd be down a bit in the middle of the pack, just above banks maybe?

[Omniscientbull]

I agree with Velco's ranking.

[beastiebull]

Oh, I forgot Denson, where would he fit?