will usc ever lose a step

[windbane]

I said I'm not sure why you think you know more than NFL analysts or knowledgable football fans because they disagree with you.  

Would you say a minor league all-star team could beat an experienced MLB team?

What about basketball where physicality means a little less than football? Could Duke this year beat the worst NBA teams?

[smazza]

Would you say a minor league all-star team could beat an experienced MLB team? interesting question

it would  depend on many factors

obviously i think usc is loaded with talent and some nfl teams suck

usc losing once in 34 games doesn't really hurt my argument

[windbane]

every pro level team in any sport is automatically an all-star squad of the lower level.  doesnt that register with you at all?  add the experience they have and it's pretty clear why they would win.  if the players in the lower level were better than the pro players, then why are they still in college or minors?

even in college football where the players have to be 3 years out of high school, there is a reason for that, they are still developing.  while I am against the age limitations, there are reasons for that rule.  and still, EVERY nfl team is a collection of college stars.  

but apparently you will never accept that.  USC losing 1 game in 35 doesnt hurt yoru arguement at all, but there was never a legit arguement to begin with.

[smazza]

lets see

i have watched nfl my entire life

i have seen usc play almost all of their games except maybe 4 in last 3 years

usc's teams of last year and this year were easily capable of beating nfl's worst teams

no offense but this old dog will stick by judgment that has gotten me this far

[windbane]

fair enough, I'll agree to disagree.  having watched sports of all kinds for years, especially football, there's no way I'd ever agree with you that a college team could beat an NFL team.  I'd like you to reexamine what all the USC players are doing several years from now, though.  then compare them to all the college all-stars the 49ers have now and see who had more.  until then...

[smazza]

please remind me in several years we had this discussion