He may get one more year. I doubt he gets his 4th season if he does not improve on 4-8. 5-7 might get him his 4th if those losses are competitive. I know it does not seem fair to the coach to have just 3 seasons to correct the Holtz New Error, but this is a new AD and Harlan may not trust that CWT can get the job done. If it was the AD that hired CWT then he would have a better chance at getting a 4th season.
You people love to blame Holtz, mainly because he is the one who followed Leavitt, but he actually coached games where he beat major programs: 2010 CincinnatiRutgersMiamiClemson - our last bowl game 2011 Notre DameOk, from that point the wheels fell of Holtz's bus. However, many of those losses were close. Taggart would not even sniff a win against any of those teams. The excuse that "those were Leavitt's recruits" does not apply, because as far as I know, the players were not coaching themselves. Also,several high profile high school coaches in the area publicly stated that they would recommend their players not sign with USF after USF fired Leavitt. Holtz had a hard enough time following up after Leavitt, and that did not help at all.
Sure firing Leavitt was the initial error, if you discount the premise that all he had to do was not try to cover up his actions and just say "I'm sorry" and he would have kept his job. However, firing Holtz was the second major error. It stank of DW desperate to save face. Instead it backfired in our face. CWT was what, 7-5 in his last season at WKU? That is not an "up and coming" coach in my book.
And to see that USF had bigger wins when Holtz was the coach then what CWT has had is very discouraging to all of us USF fans. Seems that we traded a coach that is better game day coach ( that can win some big games) for a coach with little experience but can recruit good. We have to get it right on the next hire if there is going to be one.
Holtz got to play with Leavitt's players; Taggart has had to play with Holtz's. Tough spot for CWT to be.