I too can understand why he has that opinion. Me, I look at it from a rational point of view and think USF proved, when playing a Big East schedule with many teams the fans have heard of while having a competitive team, they can pull in 40 to 50k on average a game. I would like to think that is taken into consideration along with the points you made. Now, being considered and actually receiving an invite are two different things. The only outright issues are the lack of a "name brand" and the distance from the Pac4.
From an emotional point of view, it is frustrating that the two most active times in realignment happened when the football team was at it's valley.