RB is a completely different animal from QB. With a talented RB like Hall a staff needs to recognize the talent, gear the play calling around him, and adapt the offense. With a QB, it takes time for him to learn the system, learn what defenses are giving him, to learn how to read and react. Timing is of the essence for a QB, and it takes time for a QB. In today's complex offensive schemes its difficult to find a QB you can just hand the ball to, and watch him make plays. Most QB's take years to develop proper vision, a proper acumen at reading defenses and having the proper instincts to react appropriately, to adjust to the speed of the new game, and so on. Bien,.............really! c'mon! Complex Offense you are a beeter analyst than that. We didn't even start using Andre effecetively until the 4th or 5th game. Then he'd run for 85 to 100 yards in the first half and then get the ball 5-6 times in the second half. Every run can't be 25+ yards but keep giving him the rock. So you won't win that arguement with me. Also calling hand offs???? you can't give a coach credit for that its part of their normal duties. A good OC goes above and beyond and Hobbie simply doesn't. You have swayed me to believe that Rod S should also go as he has worked with PJ and his mechanics and poise are still spotty and that's a Qb coaches job is to get the most out them and I don't think he has done that...Final question why all this loyalty MH?