Jump to content

theman123

Member
  • Posts

    5,591
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    3

Posts posted by theman123

  1. Also, everyones just talking about money, money, money. 

    I doubt Marlon's dream was to play RB for USF. His dream, and primary professional goal, was likely to play in the NFL, and clearly everyone was right in saying he'll have a great chance to do that if he left now. If he stayed, that dream is not so certain (injuries, poor season, etc.).

    • Upvote 2
  2. 2 hours ago, Orlando Bull said:

    I don't know if that is true. Not sure if you ever got to see Hall play. I honestly won't say one way or another. They are different. I will say that Hall had a different situation. When the USF offense lined up in 2005, the defense set up to stop Andre Hall. I don't think people had to game plan for Mack the same way. Sure, he's a threat, but, with Flowers' running ability and the deep threat, defenses couldn't focus solely on Mack.

    Hall was also only a 2-year "star" for us in a time where we didn't get any press at all. No one knew really about him. Our offense the last 2 seasons got a ton of attention. Ironically, to me, Mack showed more of his NFL ability in his freshman year when he was a true between the tackles running back.

    Draft status or not, Hall never really got a shot because back then, the NFL was a workhorse RB league. In 2006, there were 10 guys that had over 300 carries. Last year, there was 1. In 2006, the average carries for the top-10 guys was 338, in 2016, it was 279. Teams are relying on more of a RBBC approach now and generally will draft to have a solid 3-deep lineup. Back then, teams had 1 guy and a decent backup.

    Honestly, the 1 game that Hall really got a shot, he did very well (150 yards total), but, I think he may have tweaked something and fell out of the rotation. I don't know about his work ethic and what he was showing the coaches, but, I felt like he had the right skill set to do very well, it just never materialized.

    Mack has the opportunity to do great things in Indy. It's a perfect situation. However, from this minute forward, he has to work on blocking for the QB. Luck has spent more time on his back than any other QB in the league since he's been there. If Mack really wants to get a great opportunity, he needs to focus on protecting the franchise. Indy is weird, they generally don't go with the best runner on earth, they want a guy that can pick up a blitz and keep the QB on his feet. If Mack can do that, I have no doubt that he will shine when he gets the ball.

     

    I did see him play, great player. But, I still don't believe he was better than Mack. I think you're best argument is the fact that the NFL has moved to a RBBC approach. Andre was the focal point of the offense in 2004-2005 largely because he was taking handoffs from Pat Julmiste, not too many defenses had to worry about him.

    It's a tough argument to have, especially more than 10 years apart, but Mack was i believe the 13th or 14th RB taken while there were 17 RB's taken in 2006, and Andre wasn't one of them. Not even close to apples to apples, but just right there it shows that Mack was simply more highly regarded by the NFL than Andre was.

  3. On 4/29/2017 at 0:28 PM, Bourbon Bull said:

    I thought Andre Hall was a can't miss yet he did.  I wish Marlon the best but our former players on O really don't have a great track record.  Somebody has to be the first.

    There is a reason Andre Hall didn't get drafted and Marlon did. Marlon's a better football player at this stage in his career.

  4. Quick scroll through Collin Sherwin's twitter has me excited. 

    So if practice is any indication, #FlowersForHeisman needs to be a thing all year long.

    Been coming to USF Football practices since 2002. The most depth of talent & competition I've ever seen out here. Really impressive.

    • Upvote 4
  5. I really don't think retread is the way to go with the condition of our program. It will take a lot of energy, and patience to get this team rolling. Just not sure someone who just spent six years getting smacked around the ACC is the guy to get it done.

    Don't think I've ever been this disinterested in a head coaching hire at USF. 

×
×
  • Create New...

It appears you are using ad blocking tools.  This site is supported through ads.  Please disable in order to enjoy full access to The Bulls Pen.  Registration is free and reduces ads.