2009 was the best recruiting class imo, then Leavitt was gone. I think 2010 would've been even better considering the kids the staff was targeting.
2009 was easily one of our top classes... the 2013 class will have its shot...
here is a few sad faces from 2009:
Adaris Bellamy - 4 star... never step foot on campus
Bradley Battles - 4 star... hasn't done a single thing
Leslie Sitrrups - 3 star... kicked off the team for smoking too much
Proof that stars mean absolutely nothing.
I think Holtz and Leavitt recruit very different players. Leavitt seemed to go after talent at all costs, while Holtz targets players that fit well with his system. I feel like ever since Holtz has taken over our program, we have been recruiting players who stay out of trouble and are high character athletes. We haven't any arrests or off-the-field issues and our APR is still steadily improving.
If it's a trade-off between bums who will do more activities off the field than on, and high character athletes who stay out of trouble, but win fewer games, I would always opt for the latter. I would rather win games the right way than compromise the integrity of the program.
Having said that, I think our recruiting has been fairly consistent with our new coach. If you want to rate based on stars, this year has potential to be our best recruiting season yet.
Come on dude, if Holtz's "talent" was that much better, how do you square that with last year? Are you then saying that the coaches were "bums" last year?
High-character with low winning percentage means crap in competitive college football. Once Holtz and crew prove that their "high character" recruits can actually win consistently, then you can start your chirping......in the prism of last year your comments are all as hollow as a chocolate Easter bunny.
I never said Holtz's recruit were more talented. I think, if anything, Leavitt's recruits were far more talented if we're only considering performance on the field.
We had a very bad year last year, but let's not pretend that Leavitt ever led to us to significantly better seasons with his recruits. At this point, Leavitt and Holtz have had pretty similar accomplishments here at USF. And, to be fair to Holtz, he's only in his third season here. He's still playing with a QB that he didn't recruit.
Before you judge Holtz, you should be giving him another year. He has not been here that long. I think this year we will get a better idea on how his recruits perform on the field.