BCS started in 1998, I think.
So, from 1998-2004 as a Non-AQ, USF's record vs AQ is 1-7, which is good for a Non-AQ vs AQ win pct. of 12.5%
Notes: 2/8 (25%) of those games were vs ranked competition.
Comparatively speaking, from the start of the BCS era to their start in an AQ conference (1998-2012), UCF went 4-43 which is good for a Non-AQ vs AQ win pct. of 9.3%
Notes: 15/47 (31.9%) of the games were vs ranked competition.
From 2005-present, USF's record vs AQ teams as an AQ team is 33-48, which is good for a win pct of 40.7%
Notes: 22 of the 81 teams faced were ranked at the time, good for 27.1%
UCF's record vs. AQ teams as an AQ team is 5-1, good for a win pct of 83.3%
Notes: 2 out of the 6 teams were ranked, good for 33.3%
Fixed!