Bowls Ranked

[Jason Pryor]

On 12/3/2018 at 1:45 PM, cophbulls said:

 

Just for funzies and because, again, I am a giant data nerd. 

Using total wins as a proxy for fan interest (WinsT1+WinsT2), current Sagarin scores as a proxy for total team strength (SagScoreT1+SagScoreT2, higher is better), and the absolute value of the difference between the two scores as a proxy for the variation of strength between the two teams (ABS(SagScoreT1-SagScoreT2) lower is better) and then ranking the three measures and then summing the ranks (lower is better) I came up with a somewhat objective emotionless value to rank the bowl games. Interestingly UCF's game should, according to this theoretical model, garner the most interest. 3rd in combined wins, 7th in total team strength and 6th in comparative difference between the teams. The Gasparilla Bowl landed right in the middle, the most interesting is that the combined strength of the two teams is 36th out of the 39 bowls but the difference between the two teams was small enough that it should be a fairly competitive game, and thus, interesting game. 

https://www.usatoday.com/sports/ncaaf/sagarin/

Rank		Combined Wins		Sum Sagarin Score		Diff Sagarain Score		Rank Combined Wins		Rank Sum Sagarin Score		Rank Diff Sagarain Score		Sum Rank Score
1	Fiesta Bowl	21		167.7		1.34		3		7		6		16
2	Rose Bowl	20		179.7		5.02		4.5		3		20		27.5
3	Gator Bowl	17		164.16		2.32		15.5		9		10		34.5
4	Tampa Bowl	16		173.33		1.95		20		6		9		35
5	Cotton Bowl	24		188.72		11.74		1		2		38		41
6	Orange Bowl	23		193.82		12.44		2		1		39		42
7	Dollar Bowl	19		133.4		0.78		7		31		4.5		42.5
8	Armed Forces Bowl	18		144.79		1.59		11		26		7		44
9	Sugar Bowl	20		175.12		10.88		4.5		4		36.5		45
10	First Responder Bowl	17		155.64		2.38		15.5		19		11		45.5
11	Santa Clara Bowl	15		156.66		0.64		26		17		3		46
12	Peach Bowl	19		174.62		8.66		7		5		34		46
13	Citrus Bowl	18		166.81		7.41		11		8		30		49
14	Orlando Bowl	18		163.21		7.35		11		10		29		50
15	Boca Raton Bowl	16		134.38		0.22		20		30		2		52
16	Las Vegas Bowl	17		158.44		5.4		15.5		16		21		52.5
17	Holiday Bowl	17		160.77		6.45		15.5		12		25		52.5
18	Alamo Bowl	18		159.97		7.17		11		14		28		53
19	Camellia Bowl	16		130.52		0.1		20		34		1		55
20	Pinstripe Bowl	14		158.94		3.1		32		15		15		62
21	Gasparilla Bowl	16		128.32		1.72		20		36		8		64
22	Arizona Bowl	15		130.36		0.78		26		35		4.5		65.5
23	Independence Bowl	15		146.85		3.31		26		24		16		66
24	Military Bowl	16		147.89		5.51		20		23		23		66
25	Music City Bowl	13		160.09		4.79		36.5		13		19		68.5
26	Birmingham Bowl	14		145.78		2.44		32		25		12		69
27	Liberty Bowl	14		162.47		7.13		32		11		27		70
28	New Mexico Bowl	19		144.72		10.88		7		27		36.5		70.5
29	Phoenix Bowl	14		148.77		3.35		32		22		17		71
30	Detroit Bowl	13		151.03		2.87		36.5		21		14		71.5
31	New Orleans Bowl	18		141.42		9.94		11		29		35		75
32	Charlotte Bowl	14		152.23		5.93		32		20		24		76
33	Sun Bowl	15		155.94		8.06		26		18		33		77
34	Hawai'i Bowl	15		121.28		2.54		26		39		13		78
35	Texas Bowl	12		143.89		3.55		39		28		18		85
36	Frisco Bowl	15		124.14		6.64		26		37		26		89
37	Bahamas Bowl	15		130.93		7.67		26		33		31		90
38	Cure Bowl	13		124.1		5.46		36.5		38		22		96.5
39	Idaho Bowl	13		131.66		8.02		36.5		32		32		100.5

nice

Edited December 4, 2018 by Jason Pryor