Fair points. Let me take them 1 by 1.
Co-OC: Golesh wasn’t the co-OC at Tennessee. He was the OC. Period. But even by title, him and CJS are VERY difference. What was Jeff Scott’s calling card schematically? Any idea? I sure don’t. Their scheme relied on a Deshaun Watson, Trevor Lawrence and Tee Higgins jump balls. There was no creativity or calling card fundamentally. He was a recruiter. That’s it. Golesh is a scheme guy. X’s and O’s. He knows how to coach. And that’s a MAJOR separator.
Local recruiting ties: as I mentioned before, everyone has recruiting ties to Florida. Every school recruits Florida. You don’t have to be a local to know where to go to find talent. Additionally, this isn’t 2008. You don’t need to be buddy buddy with the HC to get a guy. NIL, winning, and ability to put up numbers gets kids in the program more than any “local ties” ever will. Look no further than Jeff Scott for this.
HC Experience: I get it. You want someone whose proven they’ve been a HC. But realize that even THAT doesn’t guarantee success. Nebraska thought they had a sure thing in Scott frost. He had been a HC! He had proven it! Failed. Gus is the worst coach at UCF out of the last 3. His resume has everything you could’ve ever wanted from a experience standpoint. We saw it here with Charlie Strong. Heck, Houston had more success with Tom Herman than they are with Dana (coordinator vs HC).
Reality: the reality is our stock is at an all time low. When you’re saying you want someone with HC experience, whose realistic? Jason candle? Chadwell? I mean, ok. But can we agree those things aren’t “sure things” anymore than Golesh? Golesh couldve taken a G5 job last year instead of going to Tennessee and dominating. If he did and succeeded, you’re not getting him. We have 3 choices: hire a young coordinator, hire a pretty mid HC, hire a retread. The coordinator choice has the highest upside with none being sure things. We can agree on that much, correct?