My take away is that Harlan knows what needs to be done and doesn't rely on message boards and instant satisfaction.
If it's better for the program, Taggart's gone... if not, Taggart gets another year
I don't see how keeping him is better for the program. His philosophy is boring, doesn't work here and is driving fans away. Are they looking to see how few season tickets they can get next year?
Easy:
1) Affordability. He's the one that knows more than anyone else whether or not USF can even afford bringing in a new coach
2) I've heard many arguments (from talk shows, news, even from other struggling programs long long ago) that firing a new coach that doesn't succeed fairly early makes it more difficult to bring other quality coaches. Most coaches probably agree (based on new coach speeches) that the first year is usually a rebuilding year and is a throw away. So now if the program doesn't produce the 2nd year they are kicked out...? Coaches want time to build up a bad program.
3) Related to #2... Harlan may have already sent out feelers and know what's currently available.
Also, unless the new coach is a splash hire, it would have little effect on attendance. Most of the ones leaving/left are tired of the losing and won't be back until the winning starts again ...
I can only speak for myself but the only way I won't renew next year is if Taggart is back. Don't need a splash hire to sell me, just some semblance of hope.